Many countries are frustrated that the U.S. isn't doing more to combat climate change

Published: 12/1/2023

As climate negotiations open in Dubai, the United States looms large. The US has done more to cause climate change than any other country. But it's also indispensable in efforts to address it.

Get these topics and transcript in your inbox

Main Topics

TopicMentionsSentiment
United States19

Strong positivity

China7

∘ Neutral

Joe Biden5

Strong positivity

Paris Agreement4

∘ Neutral

John Kerry3

Strong positivity

Jeff Brady (reporter)2

∘ Neutral

Barack Obama2

∘ Neutral

Kamala Harris2

∘ Neutral

Dubai2

∘ Neutral

Transcript

[00:00s-00:42s]: On the first day of the COP28 climate summit in Dubai, negotiators finalized a new fund to help poor countries pay for damage caused by climate change. The host nation, the United Arab Emirates, committed $100 million to that fund. The United States pledged just under $18 million. And that highlights the US role in these negotiations. Other nations are often frustrated the US isn't doing more as the world's wealthiest country, which has done more to cause climate change than any other nation. But it's also indispensable in addressing the problem. NPR's Jeff Brady reports. US climate envoy John Kerry delivers a positive message about US action on climate change these days.
[00:42s-00:45s]: I'm happy to report that the United States
[00:47s-00:49s]: has stepped up under President Biden's leadership.
[00:49s-01:42s]: As evidence, Kerry often points to landmark climate legislation past last year. The Inflation Reduction Act, which includes billions of dollars, to move the US away from fossil fuels and cut the emissions that drive global warming. But many countries aren't impressed. Developing nations point out that though they've contributed the least to climate change, they are often suffering the worst effects of it. And they say the US hasn't done enough to help. There's just a trust deficit in particular with the US. Nesha Krishnan is Climate Director for the World Resources Institutes Africa Office in Nairobi. She says the issue often comes down to money. Rich countries like the US promise to pay hundreds of billions of dollars to help poorer countries transition to clean energy and adapt to climate change. But Krishnan notes that Congress hasn't allocated much of the money to make those payments.
[01:42s-01:53s]: Even delivering on one of these promises for the US would really, I think, help bolster its reputation on the continent. But even as countries are frustrated with the US,
[01:53s-02:08s]: there is an understanding that it's essential for major breakthroughs such as the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement. Johns Hopkins University Anthropology Professor Navida Khan recently published a book on negotiations between the US and developing countries.
[02:08s-02:26s]: The Paris Agreement, for example, really did take Obama to do all this back channel diplomacy with China to be able to bring China to that table. A head of the Paris Agreement, the Obama administration struck an important deal with China to
[02:26s-02:39s]: limit greenhouse gas emissions, paving the way for the global deal. China and the US are the two largest economies and biggest emitters, so international climate progress often depends on US outreach to China.
[02:39s-02:43s]: This relationship is a tone-setting relationship.
[02:43s-03:13s]: A tone-setting relationship, as Lee show, with the Asia Society Policy Institute. Lee says the US-China relationship went into hibernation during the Trump administration and has been rocky under Biden. But this summer, Lee says it was rekindled, at least on climate issues. Earlier this month, climate on-voys for both countries met in California, where they committed to triple renewable energy globally. Lee says that engagement will help improve or stabilize the politics at COP28.
[03:13s-03:24s]: I think it is like an insurance policy to the UN climate summit. An insurance policy that at least the meeting won't be a failure, says Lee.
[03:24s-03:50s]: Still, nobody expects something on the scale of the Paris Agreement in Dubai. The conference could adopt the US and China renewable energy commitment and make more progress on finance issues that may be enough to call it a success, considering the other geopolitical challenges in the world now, such as the wars in Ukraine and Israel. But people like Denise Fontanelia say the world needs more to meet the scale of the climate problem.
[03:50s-04:01s]: It's just high time that the United States has to come to terms with its role in global warming. Fontanelia is with the Institute for Climate and Sustainable Cities in the Philippines.
[04:01s-04:03s]: She isn't expecting much from this climate summit.
[04:03s-04:15s]: I certainly hope that the US will surprise me and other people watching the negotiations. I would love to be proven wrong. But another indication that success may be modest,
[04:15s-04:32s]: instead of President Biden attending this year's climate summit, as he did the last two years, he's sending Vice President Kamala Harris in his place. Jeff Brady and PR News.